Translate

Friday, October 24, 2014

An article by, Christine Rider on: Berea College and the Absorption of Scholarships


     
     Nearly a month ago, a young lady that studies at Berea College, entered my store. She perused our newspaper section, and found an article that she had written, and was published in the Berea Citizen.  I asked what her article was about and she briefly explained, that it was on the absorption of students scholarships, at Berea College, and how it effects the students. I assured her that I would read it soon. Once she left, I went through the paper myself and found the article.

     My store is less than a half mile from Berea College, and as I was reading I couldn't help but to think of the many of the students I know. Most are bright, talented, driven, and intelligent people. Many of which are scrounging up change just to buy a snack, or a cup of coffee to stay alert through studying. I've become friends, and acquainted with many young scholars attending Berea. A lot of times I let a select few of the students have some free coffee, or something of that nature,  because I know they are just trying to get through class, or long hours of writing and studying for exams.

     I know many of the students I encounter are brilliant beyond measure, each of them have the brightest futures and ability to accomplish whatever they imagine, so long as they prevail over the struggle and grind of having little income. It irritates me to know that they are capable of being awarded more outside resources to cover loans, housing, books, and at the same time supplement their income. To me that just adds to the stress of trying to meet the high standards of Berea College's administration.

     More can and should be done to raise awareness, and at this point in time a young scholar, Christine Rider, is doing just that. By exercising her voice and aiming it at the public and administration, I hope she can make a difference for herself, current, and future students of Berea College. Read her article below, published in the Berea Citizen.




Berea College and the Absorption of Scholarships: by Christine Rider

     Berea College is a wonderful place of higher education with a focus on serving underprivileged Appalachian students that may otherwise not have access to higher education. The mission set forth by the institution is noble and has benefited many. However, I believe that an improvement to the system is needed. 


     The college discourages students from seeking outside scholarships by using an individual student’s outside scholarship(s) to offset the cost of tuition for all students. This is unfair. Berea College takes these resources from the students to “further Berea’s Mission” or to “help other students attend the college.” Therefore, needy students who spent time and effort to obtain outside scholarships are unable to fully utilize the funds they earned – including their KEES money. Although the financial aid office may grant students up to $400 a semester out of their scholarships to assist with the purchase of textbooks, this is insufficient. I have presented my appeal to the staff of the financial aid, the Dean, and the President; each time I feel dismissed and unheard so now I am appealing to a larger audience.
Receiving the extra scholarship money every semester would allow students to use it on term bills, books, supplies, study materials, etc. Instead, Berea College absorbs individual scholarships and then encourages students to “take out loans” to pay their term bills and to fund educational experiences (i.e. study abroad, and faculty led trips). Students are able to use a limited amount of their outside scholarship(s) for a single trip over the duration of their entire time at Berea. Not only are students struggling financially from the inability to use these funds, this issue is compounded by students making less than minimum wage while working in the labor program.


     If someone asks why students make less than minimum wage for their work in the labor program (which we are all committed to work for as part of our agreement with the college) s/he will hear chimes of explanations including that it is actually equitable to a $22 an hour scholarship to help pay tuition. This theoretical $22 an hour rate does not materialize in the students’ hands to pay term bills, buy shampoo, or pay for transportation home.


     The fundamental problem is that Berea College takes away outside scholarship money and then claims to serve these very students. The logic is flawed along with the system. “You work for less than minimum wage to offset tuition” and “Your scholarships are being absorbed to offset tuition.” Either way, both the labor program wages and the absorption of scholarships put students in a very difficult financial position. For recipients of outside scholarships, it seems like an extremely unfair position considering they worked hard to obtain funds to help ease the financial burden of school for themselves. My suggestion is one of simplicity; allow the students to use their outside scholarships to buy books and pay their term bills, and then absorb the rest. If the institution needs money from the outside scholarships, it should at least ensure those students’ educational needs are met first. Please join me to ask Berea College to not undermine their mission of liberating underprivileged students and preparing them for success by taking from them the few resources they have earned.

20 comments:

  1. I get people can be upset about this, but if you can find a better deal elsewhere, then by all means do so. I doubt it will be as solid of an education. I doubt it will have anything as good as the labor program, study abroad program, diversity, and personal relationship with professors.
    Berea is not perfect, and I hope students know all the ins and outs of finances before making their decision, but Berea College is one of the best decisions I ever made. I will always be grateful!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's the type of response that just further propetuates the idea of "either shut up and take this injustice or get going". Nothing makes any one feel bad as working hard to get outside money and then have a taken away for use of other students. Yet, other students still experience the same thing. The article is great, and I wish things would change.

      Delete
    2. YOU CAN BE GRATEFUL AND CHANGE IT FOR THE BETTER. THEY ARE NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE CONCEPTS.

      Delete
    3. Injustice? If you give some one $1 and they give you $10 in return is that an injustice? What exactly is the injustice? Did you not know what you were signing up for?

      "Nothing makes one feel as bad" Sounds like you have not had that many bad experiences.

      There are ways to improve Berea. Is this one that needs improvement, I don't think so. I was happy to make this partnership deal.

      Delete
  2. If students with outside scholarships did not see the value in these intangible benefits you spoke of, they would not be here. I fully appreciate the fact that I have great relationships with my professors and small class sizes. I love the diversity and culture of Berea College, but as you said, it is not perfect here.
    The bottom line is that if a student cannot pay their term bill, they cannot stay. Berea serves an already financially under-privileged population and compounds financial problems by low wages in the labor program and the absorption of scholarships. It is absurd to take a student’s outside scholarship and suggest they take out loans to pay their term bill. The term bill must be paid if one is to register and continue at Berea. The financial strain put on students is severe. For those students whose educations have been interrupted because of their inability to pay while their scholarships are being absorbed, what do you say to them? If they have $1000 in scholarship money being absorbed and cannot afford their $800 term bill, what would you suggest they do?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Christine, I do not need to be told about how students at Berea have financial trouble. I am the second of ten kids, only my mother raised us, and we were on welfare. I left Berea debt free. It was because of responsible spending on my part that I was able to. I had no xbox, no car, I shopped at goodwill, and ate mostly at food service.

      So what do I suggest students do? First, realize that they have been given the better end of an investment. Berea took my Kees money. Money that would have hardily put a dent in tuition had I gone elsewhere, and they gave me a lot of money in return. I came out on the better end for sure. I have friends that went to state schools who have tons of debt...despite their KEEs money. In comparison, Berea's financial "burden" is the opposite of "severe"
      Second, Students should learn to be responsible with their money.. get a summer job or a paid internship (which Berea will help you find).

      Delete
    2. Gregory: I grew up as you did. I budget well. I get my clothes from the free bins around campus. My schedule doesn't allow me to eat at food service nor does it allow me to go wait in line at the cafe. I dont get Kees money being from out of state. My EFC has been 0 all four years. Yet my term bill is over $1,000. Where am I to get that kind of money? From a tree? Last I checked it doesnt grow on trees...I would be planting one if it did. Or could i have got it from the $10,000 scholarship I had received? I will graduate in debt. why? because the money i worked for went to other students instead of to me.

      Delete
    3. How much debt? Did you have a summer job?

      Delete
    4. 3 Summers i worked on the farm. 1 summer I worked 2 jobs. I graduate in December with $1,520 currently of which i have paid down substantially. Had I received my scholarship, I could have gone abroad or traveled in these classes that I wanted to do. But, instead, as always i had to work my but off. I have been working since the law allowed me to at 15 to put food on the table. I know what it means to be in poverty. Berea can be better.

      Delete
    5. And there are alot of us students that have to deal with this. I am bold enough to say that Berea does not serve their low income students quite as much as they serve themselves. Professors have even said Berea is a business. Little of it is for the students.

      Delete
    6. Can you name a school that could have treated you better or where your scholarship dollars would have been worth more? I am sorry, but tell students of other schools about your less than $2k and see what they say.

      Delete
    7. Lastly, I can't see how you haven't earned enough money for term bills with Berea labor money and summer work. It was more than enough for me.

      Delete
    8. Dude, you need to just leave it alone... everyone's situation isn't yours. Some people are lucky and budgeting is their only problem, some aren't. Me for example. I had to leave berea for medical reasons and I now owe berea $5,000 because I had to take out a loan for 6 months worth of medicine because I have an illness that will never go away and I lost my medical coverage while I was there. Stephanie can vouch how bad my illness was, she witnessed it on a multitude of occasions. But because Berea wouldn't allow me to have an outside job, I couldn't afford my $800 a month medicine and eventually got so sick I had to leave, 'cause it was either that and get obama care or stay at school and rack up debt even though I was too sick to go to class. Also food service wasn't enough for me. With my illness I eat every 2-3 hours and food service is anything but convenient so I had to buy my own food. Even with good budgeting. And even more so, yes $300- $400 seems pretty substantial for books and stuff, but thats for those at berea who only had 3 or 4 classes a semester. But if you're like me you had 8 or 9 and that's not enough money for books with that many classes. And no, I did not over work myself. That's how many classes I had to take for my major to get 3 credit hours. And even working during the summer didn't help cause all the money you earn just breaks even by the time you get your term bill. So Yes I may have been a special circumstance. But please stop assuming that everyone's situation was yours where it was simply about budgeting. That's not always the case. Berea does need to change and stop being so much about business. That's exactly what it has turned into just like every other college. Yes, I am grateful for the opportunity I had to attend Berea and no I can't think of any other college with such an opportunity. But Berea needs to tell it's prospective students what they are really about from the get go. And also though other colleges may not have as good of a deal, at least I have a better chance of being able to stay at them under my circumstances. So in other words, I'd rather have to pay out of my a** the rest of my life for something worth it, than get something unreliable for free.

      Delete
    9. You take out loans. That is what every college student in America does. I had thousands of dollars in scholarships absorbed by Berea and I had to take out over $7,000 in loans to cover my tuition cost. That is still an insanely smaller amount of debt than any other college that would allow me to use my outside scholarships. Berea College has to make money to keep running and to be able to offer what is does for students.

      Delete
  3. Christine: Good for you. I was once told that if everyone loved you and praised you, you are doing something wrong. You have gone against the crowd instead of following in line. HATERS GON HATE lol That is why you are attacked with all of these people calling you ungrateful because at any other college it would be much more. No. Just because other colleges charge more does not mean that Berea can not be a little better at helping their LOW INCOME students. At my freshman orientation, Nancy Melton said "Berea college is NOT free." I know now what she meant. 9 semesters here and I see clearly the hardships of a Berea College student through my own experiences and through that of good friends. Its not just financially either. Anyways, you go girl. Don't let these people bring you down and keep fighting. HUGS

    ReplyDelete
  4. I applaud you, Christine, for taking the time and for being brave enough to write this article. It is a very difficult thing to stand up against a sea of people who are constantly telling you to "shut up and be grateful for what you have." The bottom line is that Berea College is stealing scholarship money for its students, claiming that it goes to the "cost of education" when in reality, it is most likely being used for other things. That's also why they never stop harassing graduates for donations. They are money-hungry, no doubt.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you everyone, for your support of Christine's article. It meant a lot that I got to share her words. I appreciate everyone that has read, shared, and supported this young scholar. I don't quite understand how one of the only naysayers started out their comment with, "I can get why people are upset", then continuously debate against it, as if all experiences would be the same as his. Regardless of opposing arguments, I stand with anything that supports the growth in students achieving higher learning.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am currently over 20,000 dollars in debt after attendance at Berea. I have worked at least 15 hours per week since beginning here my freshman year and have maintained summer jobs every year. Sometimes even working one day per week when I don't have classes. My EFC was zero and I owed 8,000 per year. This seems small, but the average Berea student is intelligent enough and has good enough academic standing to easily reduce the average state school term bill. After scholarships, I would have pocketed 7,000 per year if I had attended EKU. Berea is a great school, but does not handle some things appropriately. This is one of those things.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have to say, I really struggled when I was in Berea because of financial issues. Term bills were devastating, i was always on payroll deduction, sometimes as high as 90%. I couldn't even afford to buy books most of the time, had to borrow them from classmates or try to download them from the internet. I ended up working several under the table jobs just to afford basics like toothpaste and shampoo. My grades and overall performance suffered because of money issues, despite working 15-20 hours every semester. It was rough and I hate that my GPA reflects more on my poverty than my hard work and intelligence. I did graduate with debt, but I suppose it is still much less than typical college debt. A lot of students experience this. Overall, Berea works well, but many of us fall through the cracks.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete